Match thread

Duluth
  1. Ofa Tu’ungafasi (158)
  2. Bradley Slater (2)
  3. Sam Matenga (3)
  4. Josh Beehre (32)
  5. Sam Darry (38)
  6. Anton Segner (43)
  7. Dalton Papali’i (c) (102)
  8. Malachi Wrampling (1)
  9. Finlay Christie (73)
  10. Beauden Barrett (46)
  11. Caleb Clarke (80)
  12. Pita Ahki (18)
  13. AJ Lam (63)
  14. Codemeru Vai (5)
  15. Zarn Sullivan (47)

Reserves: 16. James Mullan (8), 17. Mason Tupaea (13), 18. Marcel Renata (71), 19. Che Clark (5), 20. Torian Barnes (4), 21. Taufa Funaki (36), 22. Xavi Taele (10), 23. Payton Spencer (debut)


Players not considered due to injury: Cameron Christie (knee, season), Corey Evans (ankle), Joshua Fusitu’a (elbow), Jordan Lay (concussion), Laghlan McWhannell (concussion), Sam Nock (concussion), Stephen Perofeta (calf), Patrick Tuipulotu (shoulder), Flyn Yates (neck)

Duluth

Spencer to debut off the bench

I think there's basically been a debut every week (Barnes, Slater, Vai, Matenga, Wrampling and now Spencer). Plus getting game time into Taele, Clark & Mullan

I'd like to see Cameron get time next week

Duluth

Tom Lambert, Ethan Dobbins, Daniel Botha, Matt Philip (c), Miles Amatosero, Clem Halaholo, Jamie Adamson, Pete Samu, Jake Gordon, Jack Debreczeni, Max Jorgensen, Joey Walton, Triston Reilly, Harry Potter, Sid Harvey

Replacements: Ioane Moananu, Isaac Kailea, Siosifa Amone, Angus Blyth, Leafi Talataina, Teddy Wilson, Lawson Creighton, George Poolman

taniwharugby

Good to see Wrampling get a run at 8, Blues need to be looking forward and it seems Sotutu has a foot on the plane already.

KiwiMurph

Pleased with that lineup. Would prefer Eklund on the bench. Hopefully Mullan can improve.

I presume Taele is 10 cover.

They are probably holding Perofeta back until after the bye.

@KiwiMurph said in Waratahs v Blues:

Pleased with that lineup. Would prefer Eklund on the bench. Hopefully Mullan can improve.

I presume Taele is 10 cover.

They are probably holding Perofeta back until after the bye.

Would assume Sullivan would slot in to 10.

TheMojoman

Where’s Hoskins? Interesting to see all 3 young loosies appear - Wrampling, Clark and Barnes.

Have been happy with Segners form too. Nothing like some pressure to incentivise you to perform.

Daffy Jaffy

Peyton finding out and then calling his parents about making his debut this weekend -

antipodean

@KiwiMurph at some point one must ask why hookers don't come into SR with the ability to throw darts.

Kirwan

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@KiwiMurph at some point one must ask why hookers don't come into SR with the ability to throw darts.

same reason backs can't put the pass in front of the player anymore? Amount of moves ruined by the player having to stop and catch a ball.

Dan54

I reckon players are still as good at throwing ball in, and passing in front of players etc.
I reckon as many missed lineouts are miss timing of jumps/lifters as ball not exactly on mark.

Same as thing that pisses me a lot when I look at passes not out in front, so many moves seem to be called and so many moving parts, an awful lot is timing of receiver as much as passer?
The whole game has got so much about complicated bloody moves etc.

Bones

Aussie Comms watching a different feed 🤣

antipodean

That's a good start!

Tim

That's an odd missed conversion

KiwiMurph

@Tim said in Waratahs v Blues:

That's an odd missed conversion

Not if you watched Beauden try and kick last week....

Bones

Geez Segner, that could easily have been classed as throwing the ball away. Why do that? Just drop it down mate.

Tim

Knock down by an Australian is not even a penalty. Against the Brumbies it's a card.

For such a skilled player BB is such an inconsistent kicker off the tee

Bones

@Tim said in Waratahs v Blues:

That's an odd missed conversion

It was even odder when the blues were leading 7-0

Canes4life

@Tim said in Waratahs v Blues:

Knock down by an Australian is not even a penalty. Against the Brumbies it's a card.

You can’t penalise Jorgensen. Come on mate.

Bones

Oh that's not a good look.

antipodean

WTF is the commentary talking about? Segner didn't do anything wrong at the ruck I can see.

Canes4life

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

Tim

That's a shocker. Arm tucked, shoulder charge.

KiwiMurph

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

There was a change in direction that will save him from red

Bones

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

He should see if there's a crusaders fan in the crowd he can borrow a jersey off while he sits in the bin.

KiwiMurph

Excellent tackle Beehre

antipodean

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

Easy YC. Dipping player and second tackler. After seeing what doesn't make the threshold, I see no reason that should be other than typical inconsistency.

Bones

@KiwiMurph said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

There was a change in direction that will save him from red

Maybe, but hard to justify when it was only ever going to be a shoulder charge?

Canes4life

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

Easy YC. Dipping player and second tackler. After seeing what doesn't make the threshold, I see no reason that should be other than typical inconsistency.

I guess, what even consists of a red card these days?

antipodean

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

Easy YC. Dipping player and second tackler. After seeing what doesn't make the threshold, I see no reason that should be other than typical inconsistency.

I guess, what even consists of a red card these days?

A flying stiff arm to the head is the minimum apparently.

The touch judges not raising their flags should have been the give away commentators

Canes4life

Fk me, that’s advantage over surely

Bones

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

Easy YC. Dipping player and second tackler. After seeing what doesn't make the threshold, I see no reason that should be other than typical inconsistency.

I guess, what even consists of a red card these days?

A flying stiff arm to the head is the minimum apparently.

Which is funny because at least there's arms in the "tackle" there.

Canes4life

@Bones said in Waratahs v Blues:

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

@antipodean said in Waratahs v Blues:

@Canes4life said in Waratahs v Blues:

Red all day there. No attempt to wrap at all.

Easy YC. Dipping player and second tackler. After seeing what doesn't make the threshold, I see no reason that should be other than typical inconsistency.

I guess, what even consists of a red card these days?

A flying stiff arm to the head is the minimum apparently.

Which is funny because at least there's arms in the "tackle" there.

You beat me to it.

Canes4life

Jeez the Tahs completely botched that,

KiwiMurph

Wonderful scramble defence