Match thread

booboo

I kind of think some of the guys most affected will want to play. Not sure if that is good or bad.

Anyway, saw somewhere suggestion that Lord will debut.

Sam W is skip for the tour as well I see.

So Lord to start with Sam? Vaa'i on the bench would be my pick.

Not going too much deeper into selection options. I'll leave that to you experts.

Bovidae

Vaa'i is going to be on the bench for Wales and France so needs a decent hitout against the USA. I am expecting him to start with Whitelock and Lord to get 20 mins off the bench. It seems BBBR will be one of the players heading to Cardiff early.

sparky

How many tickets have they sold for this?

Bovidae

Is anyone going to the game?

There is a curtain-raiser as well (Army vs Navy).

Stargazer
Stargazer

@mariner4life They read the Fern and notice the insecurity and stress some Ferners are suffering from if they don't know the exact time and date of the announcement.

mariner4life

@stargazer said in All Blacks vs USA:

@mariner4life They read the Fern and notice the insecurity and stress some Ferners are suffering from if they don't know the exact time and date of the announcement.

we could wheel out Hawkes Bay B and horsewhip the US, who gives a fuck?

Crucial

Any other ideas on team? This is what we had from another thread

  1. Ethan DeGroot

  2. Samisoni Taukei’aho

  3. Tyrel Lomax

  4. Sam Whitelock

  5. Tupou Vaa’i

  6. Ethan Blackadder

  7. Sam Cane

  8. Hoskins Sotutu

  9. Finlay Christie

  10. Richie Mounga

  11. George Bridge

  12. Quinn Tupaea

  13. Braydon Ennor

  14. Will Jordan

  15. Damian McKenzie

  16. Dane Coles

  17. Karl Tu’inukuafe

  18. Angus Ta'avao

  19. Josh Lord

  20. Shannon Frizell

  21. Brad Weber

  22. Rieko Ioane/ALB/Havili

  23. Sevu Reece

Could obviously swap some reserves/starters around (eg Coles/Samisoni and Frizzell/Blackadder).

Havent thought through the combos they may like to try at stages of the game either which could dictate bench strategy. eg does DMac start and move to 10 and maybe Jordan shifts to 15?

Bovidae

Papalii is fit again so he might start at 6 with Cane and Sotutu. Frizell to be the other loose forward in the 23.

Crucial

@bovidae said in All Blacks vs USA:

Papalii is fit again so he might start at 6 with Cane and Sotutu. Frizell to be the other loose forward in the 23.

Good call.

Frizzle has an injury, dunno if he'll be alright.

Tim

@machpants So it's looking like:

4 Whitelock
5 Vaai
6 Papalii
7 Cane
8 Sotutu

19 Lord
20 Jacobson

antipodean

Playing teams like the USA should be treated like mid-weekers. No one should get a Test cap for this "demonstration effort".

Crucial

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

Playing teams like the USA should be treated like mid-weekers. No one should get a Test cap for this "demonstration effort".

Disagree. That is like the insults NZ Cricket used to get for decades.

Just because you aren't a top tier test team doesn't mean you don't deserve to play tests.
That's the point. You are testing yourselves against another team. That's how you get better and just one reason why the ABs won't be playing a 'demonstration'.
In fact those playing need to show they are worthy of the jersey they are wearing.
We have had plenty of touring players disappear from future squads after playing second tier teams.

Crucial

Frank Halai, Francis Saili and Dom Bird would all agree that you need to show test qualities against 'lesser' teams and not treat them as 'exhibitions'.

antipodean

@crucial said in All Blacks vs USA:

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

Playing teams like the USA should be treated like mid-weekers. No one should get a Test cap for this "demonstration effort".

Disagree. That is like the insults NZ Cricket used to get for decades.

Just because you aren't a top tier test team doesn't mean you don't deserve to play tests.

Of course they can, amongst their tier.

That's the point. You are testing yourselves against another team. That's how you get better and just one reason why the ABs won't be playing a 'demonstration'.

It is a demonstration. They lost to Uruguay.

In fact those playing need to show they are worthy of the jersey they are wearing.

Like they used to do in mid-weekers? USA are so bad, there's no way we're going to learn anything new about players. An opposed training run would provide more structure.

MN5

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

@crucial said in All Blacks vs USA:

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

Playing teams like the USA should be treated like mid-weekers. No one should get a Test cap for this "demonstration effort".

Disagree. That is like the insults NZ Cricket used to get for decades.

Just because you aren't a top tier test team doesn't mean you don't deserve to play tests.

Of course they can, amongst their tier.

That's the point. You are testing yourselves against another team. That's how you get better and just one reason why the ABs won't be playing a 'demonstration'.

It is a demonstration. They lost to Uruguay.

In fact those playing need to show they are worthy of the jersey they are wearing.

Like they used to do in mid-weekers? USA are so bad, there's no way we're going to learn anything new about players. An opposed training run would provide more structure.

South African fans probably said something like this on their version of the fern just before they lost to Japan for the first time.

Kiwiwomble

@mn5 said in All Blacks vs USA:

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

@crucial said in All Blacks vs USA:

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

Playing teams like the USA should be treated like mid-weekers. No one should get a Test cap for this "demonstration effort".

Disagree. That is like the insults NZ Cricket used to get for decades.

Just because you aren't a top tier test team doesn't mean you don't deserve to play tests.

Of course they can, amongst their tier.

That's the point. You are testing yourselves against another team. That's how you get better and just one reason why the ABs won't be playing a 'demonstration'.

It is a demonstration. They lost to Uruguay.

In fact those playing need to show they are worthy of the jersey they are wearing.

Like they used to do in mid-weekers? USA are so bad, there's no way we're going to learn anything new about players. An opposed training run would provide more structure.

South African fans probably said something like this on their version of the fern just before they lost to Japan for the first time.

and im pretty sure we did before the argentina game last year, "these guys haven't played for nearly a year, probably only have 60mins in them etc"

“The only player’s that not available is Shannon Frizell, who’s still recovering from a knock that he got with the [ Ta$man] side a couple of weeks ago but apart from that, everyone else is good,” Plumtree confirmedd

Kiwiwomble

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

Yeah I certainly would not have the prat anywhere near a black jersey

MN5

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

Yeah I certainly would not have the prat anywhere near a black jersey

Sevu Reece is in the team though, what are your thoughts on him ?

@mn5 said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

Yeah I certainly would not have the prat anywhere near a black jersey

Sevu Reece is in the team though, what are your thoughts on him ?

Not a fan, can add samisoni to that as well, Reece is a double: a poach and a wife beater.

MN5

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@mn5 said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

Yeah I certainly would not have the prat anywhere near a black jersey

Sevu Reece is in the team though, what are your thoughts on him ?

Not a fan, can add samisoni to that as well, Reece is a double: a poach and a wife beater.

Cool just checking you weren’t playing favourites 😉

Bones

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@mn5 said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

Yeah I certainly would not have the prat anywhere near a black jersey

Sevu Reece is in the team though, what are your thoughts on him ?

Not a fan, can add samisoni to that as well, Reece is a double: a poach and a wife beater.

Isn't Frizzel a double (or triple)?

@bones said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@mn5 said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs USA:

@machpants seriously, there were already big question marks around him being in the team...and we've still taken him even though he had an injury before leaving?

Yeah I certainly would not have the prat anywhere near a black jersey

Sevu Reece is in the team though, what are your thoughts on him ?

Not a fan, can add samisoni to that as well, Reece is a double: a poach and a wife beater.

Isn't Frizzel a double (or triple)?

Yup think so, at least Reece can be good!

Frank

@machpants said in All Blacks vs USA:

“The only player’s that not available is Shannon Frizell, who’s still recovering from a knock that he got..........

when the girl he hit unexpectedly punched him back.

Daffy Jaffy
  1. Ethan de Groot (2)
  2. Asafo Aumua (4)
  3. Angus Ta’avao (19)
  4. Samuel Whitelock (127) - captain
  5. Tupou Vaa’i (7)
  6. Luke Jacobson (10)
  7. Dalton Papalii (9)
  8. Hoskins Sotutu (8)
  9. Finlay Christie (3)
  10. Richie Mo’unga (27)
  11. George Bridge (16)
  12. Quinn Tupaea (4)
  13. Braydon Ennor (2)
  14. Will Jordan (9)
  15. Damian McKenzie (37)
  16. Dane Coles (76)
  17. George Bower (8)
  18. Tyrel Lomax (10)
  19. Josh Lord - new cap
  20. Sam Cane (74)
  21. TJ Perenara (75)
  22. Beauden Barrett (98)
  23. Anton Lienert-Brown (53)
sparky

When did Braydon Ennor play for the ABs before?

KiwiMurph

@sparky said in All Blacks vs USA:

When did Braydon Ennor play for the ABs before?

He came off the bench in a Rugby Championship game and had played for ABs before that (vs Japan?)

Victor Meldrew

@sparky said in All Blacks vs USA:

Braydon Enno

Argentina in 2019, I think. Dunno if in NZ or Argie-land.

Victor Meldrew

@crucial said in All Blacks vs USA:

@antipodean said in All Blacks vs USA:

Playing teams like the USA should be treated like mid-weekers. No one should get a Test cap for this "demonstration effort".

Disagree. That is like the insults NZ Cricket used to get for decades.

Just because you aren't a top tier test team doesn't mean you don't deserve to play tests.
That's the point. You are testing yourselves against another team. That's how you get better and just one reason why the ABs won't be playing a 'demonstration'.
In fact those playing need to show they are worthy of the jersey they are wearing.
We have had plenty of touring players disappear from future squads after playing second tier teams.

Absolutely spot on.

Another plus is it gives the game credibility in the US and helps it grow there.