@jimmyb said in Reds v Chiefs:
@Bones you asking me to be reasonable and level headed?
Jordan would have got him
Reds
Match thread
Chiefs
@Bones said in Reds v Chiefs:
@jimmyb said in Reds v Chiefs:
@Bones you asking me to be reasonable and level headed?
Jordan would have got him
Jordan would have stripped it and ran 99m downfield to score
@Donsteppa said in Reds v Chiefs:
@Bones said in Reds v Chiefs:
@jimmyb said in Reds v Chiefs:
…..
Come on man, that was absolutely doing any defender
Gave him plenty of width as a start.
Imagine the moan if Dmac had already shuffled out leaving a gaping hole inside
Phrasing
Well Jacomb won’t look out of place in the Highlanders with crap kicks in the opposition half like that
@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Chiefs:
Turinui is unprofessional
The story of rugby commentators as old as time.
@KiwiMurph 22 tackles for the game. And most of them good ones as well
Game has opened up in the last 10 mins as the defence on both sides starts looking very tired.
@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Chiefs:
Wallace has had a very good game. Been impressed with his defence
That game will improve his impact stats
@Donsteppa and the ref started reffing the breakdown
@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Chiefs:
Wallace has had a very good game. Been impressed with his defence
I agree he's played well but that said it looked like Jacobson tackled Wilson without the ball off the back of that scrum which explains the waltz in to the try line
@Canes4life I hate these stats as much as the next person (ie a player can top the tackle count but 70-80% of them can be the second man in) but he’s been busy and largely effective. Few weak hits however
@brodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Chiefs:
Wallace has had a very good game. Been impressed with his defence
I agree he's played well but that said it looked like Jacobson tackled Wilson without the ball off the back of that scrum which explains the waltz in to the try line
Nah - Wilson had illegally detached.
@Canes4life said in Reds v Chiefs:
Refs getting booed off the field by the fans. Lol.
Must be Canberrans on holiday.
They should be directing their irritation at the TMO.
@antipodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@brodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Chiefs:
Wallace has had a very good game. Been impressed with his defence
I agree he's played well but that said it looked like Jacobson tackled Wilson without the ball off the back of that scrum which explains the waltz in to the try line
Nah - Wilson had illegally detached.
That doesn't matter. According to the laws tackling a player without the ball is dangerous play which overrides the other infringement.
The Aussies have a well justified inferiority complex when it comes to rugby. Their commentary is so hard to listen to.
That said not a great reffing performance - just all over the place.
DMac is getting worse for me. Always had that ability to break a game open. Nowadays just seems to have lost a bit of speed and confidence. Still very good but the edge has gone I think. Always better at fullback where his sideways running is more effective.
@brodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@antipodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@brodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@KiwiMurph said in Reds v Chiefs:
Wallace has had a very good game. Been impressed with his defence
I agree he's played well but that said it looked like Jacobson tackled Wilson without the ball off the back of that scrum which explains the waltz in to the try line
Nah - Wilson had illegally detached.
That doesn't matter. According to the laws tackling a player without the ball is dangerous play which overrides the other infringement.
Nah - if you're going to cheat like that, you take the medicine.
Tim Horan doubling down on the refs but only the calls that went against QLD. What a fucking loser.
What a feral crowd and terrible commentary. Horan has a grating voice to begin with but he was channelling his inner-Marshall.
Playle wasn't great but the Reds got away with a lot at the breakdown and Wilson should have been penalised for direct contact to Tupaea's head.
Lord went off before HT (35 mins) so it must have been an injury/HIA. But according to the main commentator he was still playing in the 2nd half.
@Bovidae said in Reds v Chiefs:
Lord went off before HT (35 mins) so it must have been an injury/HIA. But according to the main commentator he was still playing in the 2nd half.
I'm fairly certain I saw him in the 2nd half but it is Friday and I'm a bit tired.
@Bovidae said in Reds v Chiefs:
Lord went off before HT (35 mins) so it must have been an injury/HIA. But according to the main commentator he was still playing in the 2nd half.
seamed to be walking around afterwards fine so maybe HIA
@brodean said in Reds v Chiefs:
@Bovidae said in Reds v Chiefs:
Lord went off before HT (35 mins) so it must have been an injury/HIA. But according to the main commentator he was still playing in the 2nd half.
I'm fairly certain I saw him in the 2nd half but it is Friday and I'm a bit tired.
Na Mate, I will say at quick glance you could get him and Sa mixed up though.
Thought the refs stuffed up a bit, but still don't know for sure that was a try by reds on halftime. Needed to see side angle for me. Anyway it wasn't given so it wasn't, same as Wilson head on head contact in tackle with Tupaea, which was most probably ripe for a YC.
Enjoyed game, was amused at commentators saying the crowd are upset with ref early. F*** me I was at Suncorp for a hell of a lot of super games over about 15 or so years I lived there, they were always upset at refs every bloody game. Last night I sure I heard booing as Chiefs came onto field at start of game.
I’m not into loading on officials and regardless of the reactions of commentators and the crowd all 4 officials need to have a long look at their on field performance
Not taking a look at the Reds try before halftime when a grounding could be clearly seen beggared belief
Is the TMO not in place to make the correct decision?
If the boot was on the foot I have no doubt if the game was played in Hamilton the crowd reaction would have been the same.
Be an interesting review for this officiating team come Monday morning
if Marcus Playle gets another game this season I will be surprised
Not sure how you miss 3 possible knock ons in a lead up to try and your still confident enough to award the try
At the end of the day the Chiefs deserved the victory and the JTA’s lack of discipline at a crucial time was a coach killer
Plenty of class from Fraser McFreight in the post match interview to keep his emotions in check