@pakman said in AB squad for the EOYT:
Am assuming Coltman is the preferred third hooker
I'm not sure.
Normally they take 6 props when they go to SA, this year they took 5. I think Coltmans utility value was useful if there was two props injured on tour
For the EOYT they'll have 6 props again and I wouldn't be surprised to see Parsons back if fit
@pakman said in AB squad for the EOYT:
By my reckoning, if one assumes Todd drops out for Cane, there are 34 ABs in the squad at present, including Seta T. Hansen has apparently said they're taking 36 -- so two newbies before any replacements. Rieko Ioane must be likely, possibly at expense of Seta. Of the six extras who attended the Auckland camp, ALB, DMac, Seta and Todd are already in the extended squad. The remaining two are Luataua and Nanai, both of whom could feature. Am assuming Coltman is the preferred third hooker. If another prop is taken Hames could have inside running after debut. However, tighthead would be the most useful area to blood someone -- no idea if there are any comers in NPC! Suspect locks are taken care of -- the clamour for Bird seems to have trailed off. In loosies, I expect they won't take Dixon and Todd -- so one of these will be unlucky. Probably room to take one extra on tour -- so it appears the choice could be two of Dixon/Todd/Luatua/Akira Ioane.
Have I missed someone who has clearly put his hand up?
Atu Moli
i personally wouldn't bother with either ioane yet. we have strong depth in the loose - including guys like luatua and dixon, who have played better than akira in super rugby, but who haven't been given a decent crack at the higher level yet.
rieko/reiko maybe, but given ALB has gone from injury call up to definite, i reckon that is his spot gone.
@reprobate said in AB squad for the EOYT:
rieko/reiko maybe, but given ALB has gone from injury call up to definite, i reckon that is his spot gone.
He should be selected as a winger
@pakman Good analysis. I have 32 guys in the current squad plus Cane and Cruden minus Todd (he seems no certainty, so I have minused him initially). So there are 33 players locked in and three to be added.
I think they will take six props, and the sixth will be Hames, a LH, as they clearly prefer Tu'ungafasi as a TH currently. Crockett is the oldest All Black in the current squad and is potentially doubtful for RWC 2019 (though he mused recently that he currently felt fit enough to get there. Also, he and Moody share gametime all season long so he is not heavily raced during the season).
Ditto they need to find Kaino's successor, as a few have stated above. It seems Dixon, Squire, Luatua and maybe A. Ioane are still the candidates (also as 8 cover). It would be very tough on Dixon to axe him given he's played five minutes of test rugby in the RC. I think they'll take Matt Todd on the EOYT, and he'll start against Italy and France (Ardie on the bench for all four games) and keep Cane's workload down. That means no room for another 6/8 after Dixon and Squire. There's a huge logjam of talent there which is bad luck for some.
I don't think they will take any extra midfielders, given that SBW and (hopefully) Ngatai are back next year.
My 36th guy will be an outside back (even though NMS will be back next year), probably R. Ioane with Melani Nanai an outside chance.
Todd will only go if there is an injury cloud over Cane.
For me Dixon goes because they probably see him as that emergency 7 option that also plays 6 and 8.
I'd be pretty surprised if Squire doesn't go. Not only that I think he will feature quite a bit.
I know there's many keen to get Akira in there, but for what role?
I do like the prospect of his brother on the wing though. I don't think he's a natural midfielder and he's yet to develop into one.
What's the go with the locks. Tuipoluto and Romano were sparingly used but are both highly regarded by the selectors. Neither have the engines of the top two, but I'm not sure if there are any other locks running around that would be better than PT and LR at this point.
@ACT-Crusader said in AB squad for the EOYT:
Todd will only go if there is an injury cloud over Cane.
For me Dixon goes because they probably see him as that emergency 7 option that also plays 6 and 8.
I'd be pretty surprised if Squire doesn't go. Not only that I think he will feature quite a bit.
I know there's many keen to get Akira in there, but for what role?
I do like the prospect of his brother on the wing though. I don't think he's a natural midfielder and he's yet to develop into one.
What's the go with the locks. Tuipoluto and Romano were sparingly used but are both highly regarded by the selectors. Neither have the engines of the top two, but I'm not sure if there are any other locks running around that would be better than PT and LR at this point.
Dominic Bird has been massive all year, both for the Chiefs and Canterbury. I don't really get why he wasn't in the squad in the first place, but I doubt this will be one of the few changes they'll make for the EOYT.
@Stargazer said in AB squad for the EOYT:
@ACT-Crusader said in AB squad for the EOYT:
Todd will only go if there is an injury cloud over Cane.
For me Dixon goes because they probably see him as that emergency 7 option that also plays 6 and 8.
I'd be pretty surprised if Squire doesn't go. Not only that I think he will feature quite a bit.
I know there's many keen to get Akira in there, but for what role?
I do like the prospect of his brother on the wing though. I don't think he's a natural midfielder and he's yet to develop into one.
What's the go with the locks. Tuipoluto and Romano were sparingly used but are both highly regarded by the selectors. Neither have the engines of the top two, but I'm not sure if there are any other locks running around that would be better than PT and LR at this point.
Dominic Bird has been massive all year, both for the Chiefs and Canterbury. I don't really get why he wasn't in the squad in the first place, but I doubt this will be one of the few changes they'll make for the EOYT.
well who would he replace? The coaches seem to really like Romano, PT is a player on the up, so am guessing just unlucky to be sitting behind them, who are stuck behind Whitelock and BBBR...plus he should be behind any Hurricane lock as they deserve a quota according to Winger.
It worked, dammit.
@reprobate is on my list now too, and @Hooroo for being a smartass.
@taniwharugby I'd say it would have to be PT as he's no from Canterbury.
@Bones said in AB squad for the EOYT:
@taniwharugby I'd say it would have to be PT as he's no from Canterbury.
Exactly
@ACT-Crusader said in AB squad for the EOYT:
My bolter is Jordie Barrett. Covers 10/12/15/wing/lock.
Select him for the EOYT. Then never again after he starts playing for the canes. Watch winger go postal.
@reprobate Rieko might yet go as an apprentice like Ardie did a few years back, but he's a better chance than his brother due to the competition at loose forward.
I think Todd is the only player from Arg/SA squad that misses out as he is an injury replacement for Cane.
Hames as the 6th prop.
@ACT-Crusader said in AB squad for the EOYT:
Todd will only go if there is an injury cloud over Cane.
For me Dixon goes because they probably see him as that emergency 7 option that also plays 6 and 8.
I'd be pretty surprised if Squire doesn't go. Not only that I think he will feature quite a bit.
I know there's many keen to get Akira in there, but for what role?
I do like the prospect of his brother on the wing though. I don't think he's a natural midfielder and he's yet to develop into one.
What's the go with the locks. Tuipoluto and Romano were sparingly used but are both highly regarded by the selectors. Neither have the engines of the top two, but I'm not sure if there are any other locks running around that would be better than PT and LR at this point.
Are they taking any development type players who wont feature in games ?
I remember they did
Yeah I think with Akira, it would depend on whether they see him as a future player that isnt going to get alot of game time now, but is worth putting some time into now for development , for later
I remember a couple of years back, they took away Ardie , who didnt feature again for a while.
@Stargazer Dom Bird either starts or doesn't play at all as he wouldn't bring anything near what Pat or even Romano would bring off the bench and he's nowhere near a starting spot so yeah he'll have to wait for an injury or 10 before being considered.
@kiwiinmelb said in AB squad for the EOYT:
id
Yeah I think with Akira, it would depend on whether they see him as a future player that isnt going to get alot of game time now, but is worth putting some time into now for development , for later
I remember a couple of years back, they took away Ardie , who didnt feature again for a while.
I think Akira is too old & has played too much Super to be a development pick, Rieko could go the way Ardie did, but if Akira goes he has to be a main pick
