At the risk of offending some very specific Cleary fans - I kind of feel like going back there would be like locking yourself into a B+ coach.
On the plus side it is a huge improvement on McFadden, but on the other hand much like Elliott he is such a known commodity you know exactly what you are going to get and I just don't see the potential for Cleary to get over the hump an enter that echelon of being a top tier coach.
Kearny on the other hand - he is enough of a wildcard with such a unique background where he could be range anywhere from a C to an A+ - plus he is a Kiwi so if he does hit that Bennett/Bellamy echelon then there is a better chance he may stick around.
I'd always rather keep rolling the dice looking for the coach of a generation than settle for the 8th best coach in the league.
Maybe it's too much following the ABs - but when you hear Cleary and Kearny both went for the gig part of me though - why can't Watson open up the cheque book get both for next year - in the case of Cleary at least until another option came up.








