NC: All Blacks v Italy

Frank

Savea and Sititi should never start together. Too light, too soft

Tim

@gt12 Sititi would get fucking smashed if he tried to go back inside.

Is Proctor powerful and fast enough for test rugby? Not convinced.

@canefan said in 2026 Nations Championship: All Blacks v Italy:

Just for my steam back. Are we trying to punch up the middle like we did vs the Italians, or pushing it wide without earning the right?

Honestly it feels like we've hardly had the ball and when we do we've gone wide, Dmac has come in,messed up the backline and we've gone nowhere.

I've lost count of the rucks Proctor has had to hit after Dmac has come in.

Forwards are looking underpowered and backs more disjointed. Needs variety out wide and more directness and muscle up front.

Tim

Love and Roigard need to take control.

canefan

@Jnr said in 2026 Nations Championship: All Blacks v Italy:

@canefan said in 2026 Nations Championship: All Blacks v Italy:

Just for my steam back. Are we trying to punch up the middle like we did vs the Italians, or pushing it wide without earning the right?

Honestly it feels like we've hardly had the ball and when we do we've gone wide, Dmac has come in,messed up the backline and we've gone nowhere.

I've lost count of the rucks Proctor has had to hit after Dmac has come in.

Forwards are looking underpowered and backs more disjointed. Needs variety out wide and more directness and muscle up front.

Question is, will Rennie read the play and make changes?

Canes4life

Changes I would make for the next test.

Samisoni and Aumua in for Taylor
Tosi to start, Newell off the bench
Lakai for Sititi or Savea
Tupaea in for Proctor
Fehi onto the left

Yeetyaah

Holy shit. The most I've ever agreed with Marshall.

SouthernMann

Credit where it is due. The italians have been really food. They understand how the ref is operating.

That 12 is a terrific midfielder and that young winger shows great intent. Their forwards are going really well too.

KiwiMurph

I'm pleased Love hasnt fallen apart but he needs to hopefully show some lessons learnt from halftime in the second 40

Bones

Roigard has been pretty meh. Needs to sharpen up

His Bobness

Agree with others Savea not showing any leadership - spending a lot of time out on the wing waiting for his big highlight reel moment. Sititi clearly brought back too early and looks leery of contact. ABs being frustrated and need to keep it tighter and more pragmatic. Tight five going OK, but once again no leadership and some silly of gifting of possession like being in front of the kicker at the restart. Tighter,, more kicking required and, given the ref, more discipline required. Agree with others - Savea is done and new leadership required in this team.

Chris

This looks like last year all over again .
What has changed not a lot.
SA will slow the game down and bury us.they will not let the ABs play at speed.

KiwiMurph

@Chris said in 2026 Nations Championship: All Blacks v Italy:

This looks like last year all over again .
What has changed not a lot.
SA will slow the game down and bury us.they will not let the ABs play at speed.

That's assuming this 23 plays vs South Africa. If they do we are fucked. Hope Rennie is smarter than that

Frank

Good old woke New Zealand with the female commentator quota