@Mattasaurus said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

Have to expect that to go to RC..... bugger all mitigation there..... or are we going to to have some more consistent inconsistences...

The Samoa player dipped slightly (and I mean slightly) into contact, some have said that's mitigation. But Hori also dipped and then started to go up again before impact, the dumb arse

17-8 halftime

Can’t help thinking MacFarland is wasted in the second row.

No word on the card before half time....

I picked Samoa but they are beating themselves so far.

Some well-deserved cards in this game

That's a minimum yellow

And this is a yellow, possibly red!

How did that stay YC....... something smelly

@Mattasaurus said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

How did that stay YC....... something smelly

As I mentioned, it only takes the slightest dip for some TMOs to call that mitigation. Letter of the law etc

Card stats yellow, because of course it does

TBF up to that point the best TMO performance to date

Quick, concise, accurate

@Machpants said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

@Mattasaurus said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

How did that stay YC....... something smelly

As I mentioned, it only takes the slightest dip for some TMOs to call that mitigation. Letter of the law etc

Degroot and Tom Curry say hi....

@Mattasaurus said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

@Machpants said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

@Mattasaurus said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

How did that stay YC....... something smelly

As I mentioned, it only takes the slightest dip for some TMOs to call that mitigation. Letter of the law etc

Degroot and Tom Curry say hi....

Yup, as I said (and key point) some

Until we have the same ref doing them all, they won't be consistent, and even then probably not!

There is some dumb shit from Samoa, that tackle, from the same tit who got the yellow. He's on his way to a double yellow red

Ben lam has had a horror of a match. That will go to red.

so this should stay YC too?..... as player dropped in to it.... i genuinely don't know what to expect... (its RC for me as no need to be that high at all)

Lam will be red

More BS from the TMO over what meets a RC. Horie should have been having an early shower.

Christ when are they going to learn

Really enjoying the match

Think Samoa’s chance May have gone

If Japan had played like this against England they would have beaten them

This whole yellow card thing for HC isn't working.
Just make it an after match review and stand down the player down for the next game, stop ruining the contest!!!

@MiketheSnow said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

Christ when are they going to learn

Really enjoying the match

Think Samoa’s chance May have gone

Has now

Have they forgotten to check for HIAs now

The inconsistencies in and around cards beggars belief

Jonker the Plonker strikes again. No consistency across the games.

How did the ref and liney miss that?

Hes older now but Leitch still looks like he could have slotted into the ABs for leadership qualities alone.

Based on this performance I can see Japan beating Argentina and going through

no its consistent..... consistently inconsistent..... just a farking mess -literally brings game in to disrepute..

Not for one moment am I defending the head contacts - but I struggle to see how they consistently fark it up

I really don't understand how Horie's card stayed yellow, but Lam's gets upgraded to red. IMO both should have received red.

@Bovidae said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

Jonker the Plonker strikes again. No consistency across the games.

Jonker is not the bunker ref. If you’re going to give out at least know how the system works.

@Stargazer you and me both

@Stargazer said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

I really don't understand how Horie's card stayed yellow, but Lam's gets upgraded to red. IMO both should have received red.

I do, and I am not condoning it. There was a slight dip in Horie's case, head to head. Lam's was a straight shoulder to head with a higher degree of danger.

@Stargazer said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

I really don't understand how Horie's card stayed yellow, but Lam's gets upgraded to red. IMO both should have received red.

It has to come back to the human factor -- unconscious bias vs conscious bias.... I personally think there is a bit of both at play...

Remember its only a few weeks ago Farrell got down graded .......and then consider some of the non-citing's ...... Its a bloody mess

No clear release whatsoever, not condoning the Samoans frustrations but can totally understand

oh dear --- Samoa butchered a certain try there

knock on no try

Knock on. Deliberately

@booboo said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

Knock on. Deliberately

Now you are talking bollocks, he had both hands down to grab it and one arm was hit by the Samoan players

Ok, not deliberate

@Machpants said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

@booboo said in RWC Week 4: Japan v Samoa:

Knock on. Deliberately

Now you are talking bollocks, he had both hands down to grab it and one arm was hit by the Samoan players

First view I thought deliberate.

On replay I was wrong.

Am I allowed to say that on TSF?