Match thread

Bones

Thought a knock on was supposed to travel forward ref?

KiwiMurph

Think MABs would be better off with Kemara at 10 in this particular game

Bones

Interesting Riley is in this team - he was world class a year or two ago. Wouldn't have minded him switching back...

KiwiMurph

Nicely worked

Bones

Forbes looked like a prop when he tried to set off 🤣 great support and offload though

KiwiMurph

Cripes getting no luck from this ref

Bones

Barnes looking great on attack.

Mr Fish

Definitely a knock on from Riley.

Bones

Yeah, much more obvious than the one from Reihana earlier too

Mr Fish

@Bones said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

Yeah, much more obvious than the one from Reihana earlier too

Though if we're being consistent with how forward passes are assessed, Riley does actually let the ball go out of his hands backwards, it's momentum that carries it forward.

Torian

Reihana average tonight so far

Bones

@Mr-Fish said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

@Bones said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

Yeah, much more obvious than the one from Reihana earlier too

Though if we're being consistent with how forward passes are assessed, Riley does actually let the ball go out of his hands backwards, it's momentum that carries it forward.

I can't recall a knock on ever being considered under the forward pass laws.

Bones

Taele really should be a ten. Looks to be running the backline tonight too.

KiwiMurph

Lennox's passes a tad high

Mr Fish

@Bones said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

@Mr-Fish said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

@Bones said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

Yeah, much more obvious than the one from Reihana earlier too

Though if we're being consistent with how forward passes are assessed, Riley does actually let the ball go out of his hands backwards, it's momentum that carries it forward.

I can't recall a knock on ever being considered under the forward pass laws.

What I mean is that 'forward' isn't defined in the laws. But in the case of passes, 'forward' means 'forward out of the hands' - so why should it be any different for knock ons?

antipodean

Taele is such a terrible defender.

Mr Fish

@antipodean another point in the 'should play 10' column.

Bones

@Mr-Fish yeah it just needs to go forward, that's defined in the dictionary 😁

Bones

Get Kemara on

Mr Fish

Tackle was yuck there.

KiwiMurph

Not leading from the front there Bailyn

KiwiMurph

And Barnes gone too

Nepia

Maori are playing league.

That was a bad call. Barnes came from the back and was always bound.

What's the penalty count so far?

antipodean

Two cards and a try as a direct result of Norris who has given away a series of penalties.

KiwiMurph

@antipodean said in Māori All Blacks v Japan XV:

Two cards and a try as a direct result of Norris who has given away a series of penalties.

Could also blame Lennox for the handling error

Bones

How on earth was the ten running behind 5 obstructing players, not obstruction?