@Bovidae said in France vs Springboks:
@Jet said in France vs Springboks:
Angus doesnt want to send him off.
He wants to abdicate to the bunker.
The conversation between Gardner, the ARs and TMO was telling. Democracy ruled in the end. A tucked arm (ala SBW) is never a good look.
But a tucked arm isn't a red card. WR clarified this with the Beirne Decision.
@JayCee said in France vs Springboks:
@akan004 said in France vs Springboks:
@Steven-Harris said in France vs Springboks:
Is this a permanent Red ?
Yep
So Ireland's was a 20 min red, SAs is off for the entire match?
Correct. There's the option of issuing a permanent red under the current red card rules.
@akan004 said in France vs Springboks:
@JayCee said in France vs Springboks:
@akan004 said in France vs Springboks:
@Steven-Harris said in France vs Springboks:
Is this a permanent Red ?
Yep
So Ireland's was a 20 min red, SAs is off for the entire match?
Correct. There's the option of issuing a permanent red under the current red card rules.
i did not know that was a thing
@W32 said in France vs Springboks:
@Jet said in France vs Springboks:
@W32 said in France vs Springboks:
@Jet said in France vs Springboks:
Angus doesnt want to send him off.
He wants to abdicate to the bunker.
Geeze, rugbys getting soft eh?
For me it is yeah.
Much preferred it circa 2001 Lions Tour to 2006 approx.
Oh I thought you thought angus should have sent him off straightaway. My bad
He should have yeah based on what we have gotten used to over last 10 years or so.
My point was Angus was reluctant to do what needed to be done.
@akan004 said in France vs Springboks:
France have not played the 2nd half with a man advantage well. SA could win this.
Something we have in common with France this weekend
@Jet said in France vs Springboks:
@W32 said in France vs Springboks:
@Jet said in France vs Springboks:
@W32 said in France vs Springboks:
@Jet said in France vs Springboks:
Angus doesnt want to send him off.
He wants to abdicate to the bunker.
Geeze, rugbys getting soft eh?
For me it is yeah.
Much preferred it circa 2001 Lions Tour to 2006 approx.
Oh I thought you thought angus should have sent him off straightaway. My bad
He should have yeah based on what we have gotten used to over last 10 years or so.
My point was Angus was reluctant to do what needed to be done.
Yeah angus is a shit ref
@W32 said in France vs Springboks:
Technically he is ok, but he has zero feel for the game
That may be right but at least he knows the crap time wasting tactics by the Boks that other refs don’t even say a thing.
@ACT-Crusader said in France vs Springboks:
@W32 said in France vs Springboks:
Technically he is ok, but he has zero feel for the game
That may be right but at least he knows the crap time wasting tactics by the Boks that other refs don’t even say a thing.
lol
Huge decision from Gardner
If that try had been disallowed then we would be down to touch rugby
SA impressive
Springboks will win the WC purely because they are blooding a young ten now before it’s too late.
@sparky said in France vs Springboks:
France have gone backwards from this time last year.
It was silly of them to agree to play SA without playing another test beforehand, and they did look a tad disjointed. Having said that SA are just on another level atm.
@Canes4life said in France vs Springboks:
Springboks will win the WC purely because they are blooding a young ten now before it’s too late.
WC is years away. England will be the favorites for the next WC by the end of next year
An impressive 2nd half by the Boks. France didn't know how to capitalise on a numerical advantage.
@Victor-Meldrew said in France vs Springboks:
Does Gardner breath between lecturing the players?
It’s a thing with the two “top” Aussie refs, - him and Berry coach too much throughout the game. Berry doesn’t lecture like Gardner the school teacher, but he’s telling players far more than he should.
@antipodean said in France vs Springboks:
But a tucked arm isn't a red card. WR clarified this with the Beirne Decision.
You obviously didn't read the fine print when a player is wearing green. 
@Bovidae said in France vs Springboks:
wearing green
Good of the Frogs to try and help with getting the Boks back out of their white jerseys into green ones. (Think it was) Reinach looked like Shrek when he came off.
@Young-Hamiltons said in France vs Springboks:
The boks are well coached snd all of them know the hameplan.
It's hametime!
Last night test is up there with the Wellington one.
AE switching between forwards and backs is another Rassie master stroke . The Bulls fatties also were outstanding in the second half.
SFM again MOTM performance. He make things happen even from 15 and the main reason for the Springboks improvement since winning the WC.
Hard to get to sleep last night after this test.
@OomPB said in France vs Springboks:
Last night test is up there with the Wellington one.
AE switching between forwards and backs is another Rassie master stroke . The Bulls fatties also were outstanding in the second half.
SFM again MOTM performance. He make things happen even from 15 and the main reason for the Springboks improvement since winning the WC.
Hard to get to sleep last night after this test.
Based off an Eddie Jones idea supposedly.
Depending on how long Ardie continues to play I think NZ need to get him or Sititi to cover 12 ( if its the latter pairing with Leicester Fainga’anuku then Tony Johnson will have kittens in the commentary box )
@MN5 said in France vs Springboks:
@OomPB said in France vs Springboks:
Last night test is up there with the Wellington one.
AE switching between forwards and backs is another Rassie master stroke . The Bulls fatties also were outstanding in the second half.
SFM again MOTM performance. He make things happen even from 15 and the main reason for the Springboks improvement since winning the WC.
Hard to get to sleep last night after this test.
Based off an Eddie Jones idea supposedly.
Depending on how long Ardie continues to play I think NZ need to get him or Sititi to cover 12 ( if its the latter pairing with Leicester Fainga’anuku then Tony Johnson will have kittens in the commentary box )
or LF into the loosies...
@nostrildamus said in France vs Springboks:
@MN5 said in France vs Springboks:
@OomPB said in France vs Springboks:
Last night test is up there with the Wellington one.
AE switching between forwards and backs is another Rassie master stroke . The Bulls fatties also were outstanding in the second half.
SFM again MOTM performance. He make things happen even from 15 and the main reason for the Springboks improvement since winning the WC.
Hard to get to sleep last night after this test.
Based off an Eddie Jones idea supposedly.
Depending on how long Ardie continues to play I think NZ need to get him or Sititi to cover 12 ( if its the latter pairing with Leicester Fainga’anuku then Tony Johnson will have kittens in the commentary box )
or LF into the loosies...
The possibilities are limitless. They could swap from scrum to scrum and lineout to lineout. Endless fun.
Just seen the red card...not sure what to think about that.
Obviously no HIA is an absolute joke, but no mitigation with Ramos on his knees? Sure the Saffa used no arms, but I reckon if the 9 is near full height that would not have even attracted a penalty.
Are we in for another to be rescinded?
