All Blacks XV 2024

@frugby said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Landers92 said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@frugby said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@KiwiInLondon said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@frugby is this a wish list or inside information?

It's a guess...

You’ve just said you have heard and now you’re saying it’s a guess. I’m slightly confused. You’re full squad is a guess or those Highlander names you’re saying you’ve heard are actually a guess?

Overall squad has heard is a guess. However, as I mention in the post, have heard that the Highlanders are expected Taylor, Haig and Withy to be named (not an exclusive list so doesn't exclude Ma'u etc.)

I don't know whether they know they are in, or quite what. Withy surprised me a little bit, because he is beating Segner effectively though then again we've seen this movie before where someone turned down Jason Ryan and got the cold shoulder (being cynical, though I do rate Withy, and think there is little between the two)

Ok, I will bite. Who is rumoured to have turned down Ryan now?

@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@frugby said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Landers92 said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@frugby said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@KiwiInLondon said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@frugby is this a wish list or inside information?

It's a guess...

You’ve just said you have heard and now you’re saying it’s a guess. I’m slightly confused. You’re full squad is a guess or those Highlander names you’re saying you’ve heard are actually a guess?

Overall squad has heard is a guess. However, as I mention in the post, have heard that the Highlanders are expected Taylor, Haig and Withy to be named (not an exclusive list so doesn't exclude Ma'u etc.)

I don't know whether they know they are in, or quite what. Withy surprised me a little bit, because he is beating Segner effectively though then again we've seen this movie before where someone turned down Jason Ryan and got the cold shoulder (being cynical, though I do rate Withy, and think there is little between the two)

Ok, I will bite. Who is rumoured to have turned down Ryan now?

I've explained this before, but look at the initial reticence to Darry. Look at Sotutu. He's very much a trust-based guy. Let's be fair, Segner probably turned the Crusaders down to join the Blues just as Darry did.

@Bovidae said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@frugby said in All Blacks XV 2024:

I don't think the selectors think Riccitelli is up to the next level.

I'm not sure Taylor is either. Sure he is young but is just another under-sized hooker coming through the grades. Although I've never been a huge fan Slater does have some size to him, and is mobile.

I'm not sure Taylor is either, but they probably liken them to Dane Coles. Slater is someone who could have kicked on, but to do so really needed to be a nailed on starter. FWIW I think he could offer more than Riccitelli.

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

The issue with Aki was Hansen selecting Francis Saili over him in 2013.

@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

The issue with Aki was Hansen selecting Francis Saili over him in 2013.

That's appears to just be your personal preference, Aki didn't even start for the Chiefs in the finals games in 2013.

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

Just a general point really: if you keep more guys in the AB frame, they are less likely to leave. Kids who are barely even deserving of a super starting spot yet are not likely to leave, and are not really of benefit to the AB squad. It's better to keep those guys, because you never know when the guys ahead of them are going to have a bad injury, form fall off a cliff, or go overseas themselves.
I don't think he was that far down though - who was ahead of him: Nonu, Francis, Malakai at most - and the latter 2 not very convincing?

@reprobate Obviously Andrew Horrell.

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

The issue with Aki was Hansen selecting Francis Saili over him in 2013.

That's appears to just be your personal preference, Aki didn't even start for the Chiefs in the finals games in 2013.

And Saili wasn't even starting for the Blues in 2013 when he got picked for the mid Super AB squad....

Lol, flying all that distance for just 2 games is such a waste of staff and resources... why would they not play more games? some players will be flying halfway around the world for grand total 20 mins of rugby off the bench, how is limited opportunities like this supposed to keep players in the country? Oh gee I'm not taking that overseas contract cause I get to play half a game for the All Blacks XV. Should probably be 4 games really.

@darylmitchell said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Lol, flying all that distance for just 2 games is such a waste of staff and resources... why would they not play more games? some players will be flying halfway around the world for grand total 20 mins of rugby off the bench, how is limited opportunities like this supposed to keep players in the country? Oh gee I'm not taking that overseas contract cause I get to play half a game for the All Blacks XV. Should probably be 4 games really.

Suppose part of it comes down to being able to find competitive games. Portugal could have been fun, but that said reckon we'd still smoke em.

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

Just a general point really: if you keep more guys in the AB frame, they are less likely to leave. Kids who are barely even deserving of a super starting spot yet are not likely to leave, and are not really of benefit to the AB squad. It's better to keep those guys, because you never know when the guys ahead of them are going to have a bad injury, form fall off a cliff, or go overseas themselves.
I don't think he was that far down though - who was ahead of him: Nonu, Francis, Malakai at most - and the latter 2 not very convincing?

Aki left because he wanted to, not because he wasn't apprenticing in the ABs, he was a second year Super player and he went solely for money. He didn't leave for international rugby because he could have immediately played for Samoa.

@frugby How can it be profitable to travel all that way for a 2-game tour?

They are taking a 10 person management team and 30 players, like at least play more games and make it a worthwhile trip for everyone involved?

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

Just a general point really: if you keep more guys in the AB frame, they are less likely to leave. Kids who are barely even deserving of a super starting spot yet are not likely to leave, and are not really of benefit to the AB squad. It's better to keep those guys, because you never know when the guys ahead of them are going to have a bad injury, form fall off a cliff, or go overseas themselves.
I don't think he was that far down though - who was ahead of him: Nonu, Francis, Malakai at most - and the latter 2 not very convincing?

Aki left because he wanted to, not because he wasn't apprenticing in the ABs, he was a second year Super player and he went solely for money. He didn't leave for international rugby because he could have immediately played for Samoa.

he left for international, he was a project player, specifically signed with the intention of representing Ireland in the future. So money and internationally rugby

@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

The issue with Aki was Hansen selecting Francis Saili over him in 2013.

That's appears to just be your personal preference, Aki didn't even start for the Chiefs in the finals games in 2013.

And Saili wasn't even starting for the Blues in 2013 when he got picked for the mid Super AB squad....

Which doesn't make it the issue with Aki. It's just two players who weren't ready for the ABs only the one you don't like was selected.

@Machpants said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

Just a general point really: if you keep more guys in the AB frame, they are less likely to leave. Kids who are barely even deserving of a super starting spot yet are not likely to leave, and are not really of benefit to the AB squad. It's better to keep those guys, because you never know when the guys ahead of them are going to have a bad injury, form fall off a cliff, or go overseas themselves.
I don't think he was that far down though - who was ahead of him: Nonu, Francis, Malakai at most - and the latter 2 not very convincing?

Aki left because he wanted to, not because he wasn't apprenticing in the ABs, he was a second year Super player and he went solely for money. He didn't leave for international rugby because he could have immediately played for Samoa.

he left for international, he was a project player, specifically signed with the intention of representing Ireland in the future. So money and internationally rugby

Regardless, it wasn't not being brought into train with the ABs in 2013 that "made" him go. He's a bad example of the point being made.

@frugby said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Suppose part of it comes down to being able to find competitive games. Portugal could have been fun, but that said reckon we'd still smoke em.

The fact that the Georgia game will be played in France (where a lot of their players play club rugby) suggests this is the situation. RugbyPass says that England A is playing Australia A on Nov 18 so maybe they could have played some A teams. Hard to organise at late notice though with the NH club situation.

In the hypothetical world where Aki stayed in NZ, he doesn't crack the ABs until at least 2016, because he would have remained behind Smith, Nonu, SBW (who returned from league) and Fekitoa (who had just guided the Highlanders to the SR title).

In this hypothetical world, I reckon he possibly goes to the Blues because SBW was coming back, and Nonu had just left to the Hurricanes... or Tamanivalu didn't end up at the Chiefs (who bolted into the ABs).

All things considered, Aki possibly makes the ABs that year, considering ALB and Tamanivalu bolted in, but they were centres. I doubt he gets in ahead of Crotty or SBW, so in short, he probably still ends up leaving anyway.

Riccitelli has a very well rounded game and has been part of the ABs XV before so I would be surprised if he isn't there.

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Nepia said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@reprobate said in All Blacks XV 2024:

It helps keep the third choice guys happy and in the country which helps our depth and the quality of super rugby - we might have kept e.g. Bundee Aki.

Aki left when he was well down the depth chart. He's a poor example to use of a player we might have kept.

The issue with Aki was Hansen selecting Francis Saili over him in 2013.

That's appears to just be your personal preference, Aki didn't even start for the Chiefs in the finals games in 2013.

And Saili wasn't even starting for the Blues in 2013 when he got picked for the mid Super AB squad....

Which doesn't make it the issue with Aki. It's just two players who weren't ready for the ABs only the one you don't like was selected.

That's where we agree to disagree. I thought Aki had shown enough to be selected.

From my memory Aki was an exciting young prospect at NPC level who was finding his way at Super level. Too raw and unestablished for consideration.

Aki was nowhere near the All Blacks when he left. I don't think he would have ever made the team.

@African-Monkey Brodie McAlister was excellent fo the Crusaders in 2023, showed all the attributes needed to be an All Black (not to mention the physical size too). It's only since then that he's had injury issues.

Aki would have matured late, all the physical gifts there already and the subtleties would have come later AKA Nonu.

I’d take him in an absolute heartbeat over Jordie.

@MN5 said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Aki would have matured late, all the physical gifts there already and the subtleties would have come later AKA Nonu.

I’d take him in an absolute heartbeat over Jordie.

Nice 20:20 hindsight

@Machpants said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@MN5 said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Aki would have matured late, all the physical gifts there already and the subtleties would have come later AKA Nonu.

I’d take him in an absolute heartbeat over Jordie.

Nice 20:20 hindsight

I woulda said the same in 2017

@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks XV 2024:

If the All Blacks XV were being selected with an eye to the future, as opposed to just the current 'next best' squad, then I think we'd see something along the lines of:

Hookers (2): Brodie McAlister, Jack Taylor
Props (5): George Bower, Xavier Numia, Kauvaka Kauivelata, Marcel Renata, Saula Ma'u
Locks (3): Josh Lord, Fabian Holland, Zach Gallagher
Loose forwards (7): Oliver Haig, Malachi Wrampling, Cameron Suafoa, Peter Lakai, Sean Withy, Hoskins Sotutu, Simon Parker
Halfbacks (2): Noah Hotham, Folau Fakatava
First fives (1): Josh Jacomb
Centres (4): AJ Lam, Quinn Tupaea, Dallas McLeod, Gideon Wrampling
Wings (3): Kini Naholo, Jacob Ratumaitavuki-Kneepkens, Emoni Narawa
Fullbacks (2): Ruben Love, Zarn Sullivan, Chay Fihaki

A couple of slightly more experienced guys in there but largely forward-thinking.

But suspect there'll be some names like Cullen Grace in there.

I think that depends entirely on how far into the future you're looking.

In my eyes the form players of SR who:

1. Didn't make the AB squad, and
2. Are contracted for at least next year to NZR

should be the ones selected. Even if the AB XV is considered a development squad, it requires guys with experience to mentor the younger guys and offer an incentive in case injury/ form strikes those selected before them.

We can't just keep throwing young guys in the deep end hoping that exposure is beneficial.

You need an experienced player to captain the team. There isn't even that many provincial captains amongst the players listed. Suafoa might not be guaranteed a start and Christie would be replaced.

Co-captains would be my tip. Riccitelli and Lio-Willie.

@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Aki was nowhere near the All Blacks when he left. I don't think he would have ever made the team.

@African-Monkey Brodie McAlister was excellent fo the Crusaders in 2023, showed all the attributes needed to be an All Black (not to mention the physical size too). It's only since then that he's had injury issues.

He seemed to gain 10kg in the Irish ‘system’.

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Why does Brodie McAlister get rated so highly? He's never been a regular starter at SR level and is always injured. What is it, 40 games in 6 seasons and is 27?

For all the criticism Ricci Riccitelli gets, at least he's a regular at SR level and was arguably the best performing SR hooker this year (with Aumua).

I'm not Riccitelli's biggest fan over the years by any stretch, but he deserves to be ahead of McAlister that's for sure.

One of the most debated topics on here recently, if Riccitelli wore a red and black jersey, would that help his chances?

Corey Flynn springs to mind.

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

No, but that says more about the hooker depth than anything.

In 2020/2021, the ABs had Taylor, Coles, Aumua and Taukei'aho.

Still playing Super Rugby were capped ABs in Parsons, Coltman & Harris, with Eklund, Dixon also playing great rugby. Add in Makalio being a very solid backup for the Crusaders, and both Vikena and McAlister being viewed as good up and comers, and the situation was totally different to what we saw this year...

Taylor now playing out of his skin, Aumua awesome in Super Rugby, Riccitelli good in a great team, Taukei'aho underwhelming by his own standards before snapping his achilles.

In behind that, the Highlanders had little, the Canes arguably even less, the Chiefs had Slater doing tidy, and Thompson who for all his x-factor is way too inconsistent. The Blues had Eklund and Vikena battling for who could warm the bench for RR. Other than Bell showing good signs around the field for the Crusaders, outside of the above, the hooker landscape was atrocious.

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

10 starts in 6 years? Far out, and he's seen as an option for higher honours, whilst Riccitelli gets laughed at as an option? That'll do me.

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

10 starts in 6 years? Far out, and he's seen as an option for higher honours, whilst Riccitelli gets laughed at as an option? That'll do me.

He's had Codie Taylor ahead of him (and was injured when Taylor was out this year). Ricky Riccitelli hasn't had an All Black hooker to compete with or he would have no doubt earned far fewer starts.

Based on how Asafo Aumua has been playing off the bench for the All Blacks, maybe someone who's a specialist bench hooker at Super Rugby level isn't a bad option.

@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

10 starts in 6 years? Far out, and he's seen as an option for higher honours, whilst Riccitelli gets laughed at as an option? That'll do me.

He's had Codie Taylor ahead of him (and was injured when Taylor was out this year). Ricky Riccitelli hasn't had an All Black hooker to compete with or he would have no doubt earned far fewer starts.

Based on how Asafo Aumua has been playing off the bench for the All Blacks, maybe someone who's a specialist bench hooker at Super Rugby level isn't a bad option.

Big difference when Brodie McAlister was coming on at SR level off the bench when the majority of the time the Crusaders were well in control and up by plenty infront of half full stadiums, compared to top tier test rugby where most games are in the balance. Infact, the only thing McAlister did this year was botch that lineout against the Tahs (with the game inthe balance) which ended up costing the Crusaders the game, and also a spot in the playoffs.

Anyone could have been effective off the bench at hooker in those Crusaders glory years, even Andrew Makalio was. He didn't seem to be anywhere near as good however when he left and went to the Highlanders.

No one seems to rate Cam Millar but I think he is more suited to international rugby than Jacomb. I would take these two though.

@cgrant said in All Blacks XV 2024:

No one seems to rate Cam Millar but I think he is more suited to international rugby than Jacomb. I would take these two though.

I'd definitely take both... what is massively in Millar's favour (short-term) is that the Highlanders' 10 jersey is his, and I think at first five, to reach the All Blacks you need to pretty much be a nailed on starter. Unless McKenzie gets injured, Jacomb's best bet is starting at fullback.

@cgrant said in All Blacks XV 2024:

No one seems to rate Cam Millar but I think he is more suited to international rugby than Jacomb. I would take these two though.

He's certainly got really good skills. He reminds me of Simon Culhane skill wise but has a better running game.

Having the winning mentality is important and Millar is in teams who are only starting to win.

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

10 starts in 6 years? Far out, and he's seen as an option for higher honours, whilst Riccitelli gets laughed at as an option? That'll do me.

He's had Codie Taylor ahead of him (and was injured when Taylor was out this year). Ricky Riccitelli hasn't had an All Black hooker to compete with or he would have no doubt earned far fewer starts.

Based on how Asafo Aumua has been playing off the bench for the All Blacks, maybe someone who's a specialist bench hooker at Super Rugby level isn't a bad option.

Big difference when Brodie McAlister was coming on at SR level off the bench when the majority of the time the Crusaders were well in control and up by plenty infront of half full stadiums, compared to top tier test rugby where most games are in the balance. Infact, the only thing McAlister did this year was botch that lineout against the Tahs (with the game inthe balance) which ended up costing the Crusaders the game, and also a spot in the playoffs.

Anyone could have been effective off the bench at hooker in those Crusaders glory years, even Andrew Makalio was. He didn't seem to be anywhere near as good however when he left and went to the Highlanders.

This is an important point and I feel many of the fringe Crusaders players have been good by association - riding the coat tails of the likes of Whitelock and Mo'unga.

Tom Christie started his SR career after McAlister, has played more games and has played a bigger role in the Crusaders dynasty but not even Crusaders fans are talking about him as a potential AB.

Despite Bell's awful throwing he's shown far more around the field and has also shown in the past he can throw a good lineout. Despite only being 22 and having a couple of years under his belt Bell has already surpassed McAlister and that's not a good sign.

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@African-Monkey said in All Blacks XV 2024:

@brodean said in All Blacks XV 2024:

Brodie McAlister is 27 and made 43 appearances for the Crusaders since 2019 - 10 as a starter.

I've never seen him play a single game that suggests he should be anywhere near the ABs.

10 starts in 6 years? Far out, and he's seen as an option for higher honours, whilst Riccitelli gets laughed at as an option? That'll do me.

He's had Codie Taylor ahead of him (and was injured when Taylor was out this year). Ricky Riccitelli hasn't had an All Black hooker to compete with or he would have no doubt earned far fewer starts.

Based on how Asafo Aumua has been playing off the bench for the All Blacks, maybe someone who's a specialist bench hooker at Super Rugby level isn't a bad option.

Big difference when Brodie McAlister was coming on at SR level off the bench when the majority of the time the Crusaders were well in control and up by plenty infront of half full stadiums, compared to top tier test rugby where most games are in the balance. Infact, the only thing McAlister did this year was botch that lineout against the Tahs (with the game inthe balance) which ended up costing the Crusaders the game, and also a spot in the playoffs.

Anyone could have been effective off the bench at hooker in those Crusaders glory years, even Andrew Makalio was. He didn't seem to be anywhere near as good however when he left and went to the Highlanders.

This is an important point and I feel many of the fringe Crusaders players have been good by association - riding the coat tails of the likes of Whitelock and Mo'unga.

Tom Christie started his SR career after McAlister, has played more games and has played a bigger role in the Crusaders dynasty but not even Crusaders fans are talking about him as an AB.

That's fair.... but this is the exact same thing Riccitelli has done. He is a good solid player, no doubt, but he looked extra good because he was surrounded by a Blues pack that was dominating games.