@reprobate said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@brodean For me yes absolutely he's made some nice plays, but when you have Ioane (29) and ALB (31) on top of the 3 x super standouts (29, 27, 27) Havili shouldn't be in consideration. If you need to pick a 6th midfielder after those guys they shouldn't be 31, they should be 21.
Who would that 21-year-old be who deserves a jersey without just being given one, and not earning it.
@reprobate said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris There isn't one mate - I'd argue you don't need a 6th midfielder because it's a development slot and we don't have one. If you cop an injury you fly Havili in.
Cooper Roberts next year hopefully.
Yeah I know, Roberts looks the goods in a couple of years.
Not a ALB fan but Rennie will pick him.
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@reprobate said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@brodean For me yes absolutely he's made some nice plays, but when you have Ioane (29) and ALB (31) on top of the 3 x super standouts (29, 27, 27) Havili shouldn't be in consideration. If you need to pick a 6th midfielder after those guys they shouldn't be 31, they should be 21.
Who would that 21-year-old be who deserves a jersey without just being given one, and not earning it.
NZ-born Kadin Pritchard
Scottish legend of the future Riley Higgins is only 23...
Xavi Taele (well, you asked!)
Lalomilo Lalomilo is 27 but Milo lasts for ages..
@nostrildamus said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@reprobate said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@brodean For me yes absolutely he's made some nice plays, but when you have Ioane (29) and ALB (31) on top of the 3 x super standouts (29, 27, 27) Havili shouldn't be in consideration. If you need to pick a 6th midfielder after those guys they shouldn't be 31, they should be 21.
Who would that 21-year-old be who deserves a jersey without just being given one, and not earning it.
NZ-born Kadin Pritchard
Scottish legend of the future Riley Higgins is only 23...
Xavi Taele (well, you asked!)
Lalomilo Lalomilo is 27 but Milo lasts for ages..
No,No, No and No
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@nostrildamus said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@reprobate said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@brodean For me yes absolutely he's made some nice plays, but when you have Ioane (29) and ALB (31) on top of the 3 x super standouts (29, 27, 27) Havili shouldn't be in consideration. If you need to pick a 6th midfielder after those guys they shouldn't be 31, they should be 21.
Who would that 21-year-old be who deserves a jersey without just being given one, and not earning it.
NZ-born Kadin Pritchard
Scottish legend of the future Riley Higgins is only 23...
Xavi Taele (well, you asked!)
Lalomilo Lalomilo is 27 but Milo lasts for ages..No,No, No and No
David Havili.
tried and dusted
So
No
@nostrildamus said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@nostrildamus said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@reprobate said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@brodean For me yes absolutely he's made some nice plays, but when you have Ioane (29) and ALB (31) on top of the 3 x super standouts (29, 27, 27) Havili shouldn't be in consideration. If you need to pick a 6th midfielder after those guys they shouldn't be 31, they should be 21.
Who would that 21-year-old be who deserves a jersey without just being given one, and not earning it.
NZ-born Kadin Pritchard
Scottish legend of the future Riley Higgins is only 23...
Xavi Taele (well, you asked!)
Lalomilo Lalomilo is 27 but Milo lasts for ages..No,No, No and No
David Havili.
tried and dusted
So
No
Better than 3 no's.
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
Better than 3 no's.
Well you wanted 21 year olds mentioned.
I would have gone with other candidates.
We shall see what David Rennie chooses.
Havili is in the Christie category for me. Both handy to have around when there's an injury crisis. Both don't make my ABs squads but you know, if there's a big injury toll, then it's nice that we can call upon these guys.
Have added Kurt Eklund to the Blues confirmed departures.
Hopefully we see teams formally announcing who will be leaving shortly. The Highlanders didn't do it last year, which was disappointing. With the confirmed re-signings you'd think the next step is to confirm departures before announcing new arrivals.
@SouthernMann You’d think even if they don’t do it for the whole squad a bloke like DLB who’s the most capped forward in the club’s history would get a farewell post.
@handa457 said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@SouthernMann You’d think even if they don’t do it for the whole squad a bloke like DLB who’s the most capped forward in the club’s history would get a farewell post.
Is he not hanging around?
@African-Monkey Nothing fully confirmed. But process of elimination would say likely yes. @SouthernMann would have the most up-to-date numbers, but we've been told a dozen guys are off.
Given Millar, Haig, Kautai, Vikena, Renton, Lowe, Knewstubb, Robinson, Telea, and Lowe are either confirmed or all but confirmed, that leaves two remaining blokes from the four we don't know about: DLB, Cribb, Broughton, and Howden.
There's been some chat that Cribb is around next year, so it's probably one of Broughton or Howden leaving, and my guess would be DLB.
But equally, if anyone can survive, it'd be DLB. The ultimate journeyman. He seems like part of the furniture down south.
@handa457 said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@African-Monkey Nothing fully confirmed. But process of elimination would say likely yes. @SouthernMann would have the most up-to-date numbers, but we've been told a dozen guys are off.
Given Millar, Haig, Kautai, Vikena, Renton, Lowe, Knewstubb, Robinson, Telea, and Lowe are either confirmed or all but confirmed, that leaves two remaining blokes from the four we don't know about: DLB, Cribb, Broughton, and Howden.
There's been some chat that Cribb is around next year, so it's probably one of Broughton or Howden leaving, and my guess would be DLB.
But equally, if anyone can survive, it'd be DLB. The ultimate journeyman. He seems like part of the furniture down south.
You are trying to manifest what you want by continuing to mention Cribb. It was highly likely that Cribb picked up a two year deal for 26/27. He is there next year.
DLB is all but confirmed. With the top group. Apparently has been mentioned on private social channels or at least hinted at. He is the devil we know however, which means if we can't land a loosehead he might get another reprieve.
Mate It’s getting a bit old, you having a go every time I reply to a thread about the highlanders.
We have different opinions on a few players. That’s good. This place thrives off people who have different opinions. However I haven’t raised that here, just answered the question on players who’s contract status is unclear, then tagged you to double check if I’d missed anyone on the contracting list.
You’re capable of being pleasant. Why not choose to be?
@SouthernMann that’s news to me. But hence why I tagged you in the first place. If he’s on a two year deal then good to know.
The ‘jokes’ don’t come off as jokes. Don’t see a reason need to block anyone, when a simple conversation about communicating better should solve it.
@SouthernMann said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@handa457 said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@African-Monkey Nothing fully confirmed. But process of elimination would say likely yes. @SouthernMann would have the most up-to-date numbers, but we've been told a dozen guys are off.
Given Millar, Haig, Kautai, Vikena, Renton, Lowe, Knewstubb, Robinson, Telea, and Lowe are either confirmed or all but confirmed, that leaves two remaining blokes from the four we don't know about: DLB, Cribb, Broughton, and Howden.
There's been some chat that Cribb is around next year, so it's probably one of Broughton or Howden leaving, and my guess would be DLB.
But equally, if anyone can survive, it'd be DLB. The ultimate journeyman. He seems like part of the furniture down south.
You are trying to manifest what you want by continuing to mention Cribb. It was highly likely that Cribb picked up a two year deal for 26/27. He is there next year.
DLB is all but confirmed. With the top group. Apparently has been mentioned on private social channels or at least hinted at. He is the devil we know however, which means if we can't land a loosehead he might get another reprieve.
I heard DLB most likely gone - so confirmed leaving or staying?
Cribb said he was back next year, doesn't mean he can't get his contract ripped up, but I'd say that would be unlikely - and equally dumb considering his age.
feels like a real hollowing out year. 3-4 AB standard players, at least a dozen who are guaranteed Super level starters on top of that. All at once.
@mariner4life def looks a bigger exodus than other pre-RWC years.
potentially what happens when selection for higher honours gets....murky...not connected with form
@Kiwiwomble lets be honest here DLB and Havili weren't displaying AB standard form this year.
@antipodean i wasnt implying every person leaving should have been an AB
Every year we will lose some that we want to keep. This year seems we are seeing some lads read the room and think fuck it, we are off.
From a Highlanders perspective I am pretty happy with the guys who are moving on. None would be starting players in 2027. Which has to be a win.
The interesting numbers will be post 2027. How many guys will be looking overseas affer the world cup or if they don't get an AB shot.
@antipodean said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Kiwiwomble lets be honest here DLB and Havili weren't displaying AB standard form this year.
Havili had a very good season. But .happy the selectors have moved on
@canefan said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@antipodean said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Kiwiwomble lets be honest here DLB and Havili weren't displaying AB standard form this year.
Havili had a very good season. But .happy the selectors have moved on
I'm sure as a Canes supporter you'd think that after his performance against the Hurricanes.
That said I think at his best he deserved his All Black tenure, but he wasn't the type of player they tried to make him. Instead of being a second five-eighth, they wanted more of a bash merchant at 12.
@antipodean said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@canefan said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@antipodean said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Kiwiwomble lets be honest here DLB and Havili weren't displaying AB standard form this year.
Havili had a very good season. But .happy the selectors have moved on
I'm sure as a Canes supporter you'd think that after his performance against the Hurricanes.
That said I think at his best he deserved his All Black tenure, but he wasn't the type of player they tried to make him. Instead of being a second five-eighth, they wanted more of a bash merchant at 12.
I didn't mean it like that. I thought he played pretty well this SR season. But I did not want him in the ABs
@mariner4life Hansen factor for Saders clear out??
@Dancefloor said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@mariner4life Hansen factor for Saders clear out??
Rubbish,
older players cashing out before WC,
Another BS rumour starting up,
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Dancefloor said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@mariner4life Hansen factor for Saders clear out??
Rubbish older players cashing out before WC,
Another BS rumour starting up,
Which Hansen are we talking about?
@SouthernMann said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
Every year we will lose some that we want to keep. This year seems we are seeing some lads read the room and think fuck it, we are off.
From a Highlanders perspective I am pretty happy with the guys who are moving on. None would be starting players in 2027. Which has to be a win.
The interesting numbers will be post 2027. How many guys will be looking overseas affer the world cup or if they don't get an AB shot.
you're not wrong...my only concern is a feel depth is whats really stung us in the past....i'd love it if we could keep a couple more guys...millar i would have liked to keep
@Bones said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Dancefloor said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@mariner4life Hansen factor for Saders clear out??
Rubbish older players cashing out before WC,
Another BS rumour starting up,Which Hansen are we talking about?
Scott
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Bones said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Dancefloor said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@mariner4life Hansen factor for Saders clear out??
Rubbish older players cashing out before WC,
Another BS rumour starting up,Which Hansen are we talking about?
Scott
So what's the rumour meant to be? Was he involved with the saders this year?
@Bones said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Bones said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@Dancefloor said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
@mariner4life Hansen factor for Saders clear out??
Rubbish older players cashing out before WC,
Another BS rumour starting up,Which Hansen are we talking about?
Scott
So what's the rumour meant to be? Was he involved with the saders this year?
No he wasn't
The rumour being the Crusaders players leaving are all going because Hanson is coming back as Coach.
Stupid rumour the Crusaders are losing 6 players by the look of things.
By that standard its Laidlaw's fault 12 or 13 players are leaving the Canes,
Or 10 Blues players leaving must be because Holland is the new coach
12 at the Highlanders going Joseph's fault.
The Crusaders are actually losing less players than the other teams.
@Chris said in Super Rugby confirmed and rumoured transfers 26 - 27:
12 at the Highlanders going Joseph's fault
So it's Hansen's fault then
