@Bones said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@Canes4life I could swear you're related to Bonesetta with responses to questions that are not even close to an on topic answer.
Pretty hard to ban someone on a public forum is the point.
Might be easier to find them...
On the plus side, a "leak" that BB is playing 13 would be fun
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
@chimoaus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Is there really any advantage in naming the team late Thursday? I mean SA name theirs on what Tuesday?
And change it on Thursday 
@Canes4life said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@Bones said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@Canes4life said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Someone ban the bloke
Isn't the forum public?
I think there's largely a collective understanding that some information shared on the Fern is shared in confidence. The Myth page on FB has a large following and whoevers leaking information to that page is going against what @landers92 has asked.
Dick move in my view and I'm not suprised @landers92 is now reluctant to share that sort of information going forward.
Myth has a large following specifically because of the information he reposts from here, he's a opportunistic twat.
@Landers92 said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@KiwiMurph said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
One interesting note
Based on the above it sounds like no Preston - I wonder if its a case of not meeting markers or the plan was to give him a look vs Italy and that didnt happen as Ratima only got 5 mins vs France.
Rennie really isn’t a fan of our available halfback cattle. I know there were very short discussions about wanting to get a kiwi that’s currently overseas back into the squad somehow if it were possible. Was shut down very quickly obviously.
Having Aaron Smith back and playing 20 odd mins of test footy off the bench every week would be the ideal solution to this problem - then again, his lack of any running game might be an issue for some...
@Landers92 said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@KiwiMurph said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
One interesting note
Based on the above it sounds like no Preston - I wonder if its a case of not meeting markers or the plan was to give him a look vs Italy and that didnt happen as Ratima only got 5 mins vs France.
Rennie really isn’t a fan of our available halfback cattle. I know there were very short discussions about wanting to get a kiwi that’s currently overseas back into the squad somehow if it were possible. Was shut down very quickly obviously.
Interesting. Can't say I disagree with him.
@WoodysRFC said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Myth has a large following specifically because of the information he reposts from here, he's a opportunistic twat.
Just wait until Tony Woodcock sues him for identity fraud...
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
There is nothing wrong with that either, but also given his age, it is hard to see him being of use past 2027.
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago
You lost me right here.
Don't agree with the assessments on Moorby.
Low error rate, excellent option taker, good under the high ball, links well, can play fullback and wing.
Ideal for test footy.
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
There is nothing wrong with that either, but also given his age, it is hard to see him being of use past 2027.
Moorby showed in his debut that he has potential to be explosive, something I can't recall Bridge being
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
There is nothing wrong with that either, but also given his age, it is hard to see him being of use past 2027.
4 days over 28 years old? Send him to the knackers yard!
@canefan said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Moorby showed in his debut that he has potential to be explosive, something I can't recall Bridge being
To. be fair to George most people would avoid an explosive Bridge.
@canefan said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
There is nothing wrong with that either, but also given his age, it is hard to see him being of use past 2027.
Moorby showed in his debut that he has potential to be explosive, something I can't recall Bridge being
You don't remember Bridge's early games for the ABs?
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
@jimmyb said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
If Moorby could have half as long a fine career as Ben Smith did I'd be very satisfied!
@Frank said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Don't agree with the assessments on Moorby.
Low error rate, excellent option taker, good under the high ball, links well, can play fullback and wing.
Ideal for test footy.
Yep, just like Kahui (except the fullback part).
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Whether it is Jordie or Tupaea, Love or B Barrett, Parker or Segner, I wouldn’t expect the overall gameplan to shift that much.
I respectfully disagree on this point. I think the game plan would change a lot
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
@nzzp said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
There's a great team try highlight that pops up on the All Blacks' social media every now and then. It features everything you want to see: flowing rugby, offloads, accurate passing, players running into space and plenty of involvement from across the team. Except when the ball reaches Bridge, who stops in his tracks and goes to ground almost before the defender even touches him.
@nzzp said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
You could be talking about Doug Howlett.
@mr-fish said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nzzp said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
You could be talking about Doug Howlett.
Rubbish. Howlett could beat and a man and scored trys against more teams than Japan.
@george33 said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@canefan just an opinion.I've been hearing since the French test that Vaai would play 6. If he does start 6 what's happening to Parker will he even make the African tour .
I see 3 options.
I suspect it isn't the first as we still don't see someone clearly holding in to that 6 position.
@jimmyb said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
Smith debuted at 23.
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@jimmyb said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
If Moorby could have half as long a fine career as Ben Smith did I'd be very satisfied!
To have half as long a career he'd still be playing in our outside backs at 33, which would be pretty unusual...
@reprobate said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@jimmyb said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
If Moorby could have half as long a fine career as Ben Smith did I'd be very satisfied!
To have half as long a career he'd still be playing in our outside backs at 33, which would be pretty unusual...
Much like Ben Smith then.
@Kirwan said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@mr-fish said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nzzp said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
You could be talking about Doug Howlett.
Rubbish. Howlett could beat and a man and scored trys against more teams than Japan.
Like Bridge's tries against Australia, South Africa and Ireland, you mean?
Howlett had great speed but go back and watch his try-scoring highlights - there are only half a dozen or so amongst them that someone like Bridge couldn't also finish.
@ShaquilleOatmeal said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@reprobate said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@jimmyb said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
If Moorby could have half as long a fine career as Ben Smith did I'd be very satisfied!
To have half as long a career he'd still be playing in our outside backs at 33, which would be pretty unusual...
Much like Ben Smith then.
Yes, it would be. Care for a friendly wager?
15 - Hugo Keenan (UCD/Leinster)(47)
14 - Robert Baloucoune (Enniskillen/Ulster)(8)
13 - Garry Ringrose (UCD/Leinster)(75)
12 - Stuart McCloskey (Bangor/Ulster)(30)
11 - Jimmy O’Brien (Naas/Leinster)(13)
10 - Sam Prendergast (Lansdowne/Leinster)(16)
9 - Jamison Gibson-Park (Leinster)(52)
1 - Tom O’Toole (Ballynahinch/Ulster)(23)
2 - Dan Sheehan (Lansdowne/Leinster)(40)(captain)
3 - Tadhg Furlong (Clontarf/Leinster)(87)
4 - Joe McCarthy (Dublin University/Leinster)(25)
5 - James Ryan (UCD/Leinster)(82)
6 - Tadhg Beirne (Lansdowne/Munster)(72)
7 - Josh van der Flier (UCD/Leinster)(80)
8 - Jack Conan (Old Belvedere/Leinster)(61)
Replacements
16 - Ronan Kelleher (Lansdowne/Leinster)(50)
17 - Jeremy Loughman (Garryowen/Munster)(9)
18 - Thomas Clarkson (Blackrock College/Leinster)(15)
19 - Nick Timoney (Queen’s University/Ulster)(13)
20 - Sean Jansen (Connacht)(1)
21 - Craig Casey (Shannon/Munster)(29)
22 - Ciaran Frawley (UCD/Leinster)(14)
23 - Bundee Aki (Galwegians/Connacht)(71)
@reprobate said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@ShaquilleOatmeal said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@reprobate said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@jimmyb said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus only a year younger than Ben Smith in 2013. That worked out terribly
If Moorby could have half as long a fine career as Ben Smith did I'd be very satisfied!
To have half as long a career he'd still be playing in our outside backs at 33, which would be pretty unusual...
Much like Ben Smith then.
Yes, it would be. Care for a friendly wager?
No, thanks. I don't see Moorby making it past the World Cup next year either.
@pakman said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Irish team named.
And it’s still Wednesday over there.
Innovation.
@nzzp said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
Bridge possibly not the best example, but what I am really trying to say is Josh Moorby has been nothing more than a good Super Rugby player across his career, and then at 27, as a winger, he all of a sudden becomes this good?
It isn't meant as a critique, but the chances of this being anything other than a massive purple patch feel really low to me - and there isn't anything wrong with that. I'd far rather them play the hot hand and win now, then opt for someone like Clarke, who at the moment seems to have very little threat with ball in hand, or a project player (say a Hutchinson).
@reprobate said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
Apart from JGP, I think our backline is much better.
Stuart McCloskey is class though.
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nzzp said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@nostrildamus said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
@frugby said in NC: All Blacks v Ireland:
I am absolutely in favour of Moorby starting this week - I also don’t really see him as anything other than a stop gap.
But if he is a stop gap who wins us a Boks Tour then he will go down in ABs folklore
why is he a stop gap? Looks pretty useful to me.
Because I think Moorby is just the hot hand right now - probably not in a dissimilar mode to George Bridge a few years ago.
Hard disagree.
Go back and watch his tries when he was near the try scoring record for Super and got selected. They were bog average- typically gettin gthe ball in space a few yards out from the line iwth no defenders. If you think I'm exaggerating, I think in 12-14 tries he beat maybe 3-4 defenders. Classic example of statistics being misleading.
For the ABs his ability to beat a man was unrivalled - but in the wrong direction. He just ran into ocntact over and over. It was pitiful.
Bridge possibly not the best example, but what I am really trying to say is Josh Moorby has been nothing more than a good Super Rugby player across his career, and then at 27, as a winger, he all of a sudden becomes this good?
It isn't meant as a critique, but the chances of this being anything other than a massive purple patch feel really low to me - and there isn't anything wrong with that. I'd far rather them play the hot hand and win now, then opt for someone like Clarke, who at the moment seems to have very little threat with ball in hand, or a project player (say a Hutchinson).
Some guys develop late. Who knows if his french adventure helped in any tangible way or not. He strikes me as having the potential for a Cory Jane style career, as opposed to a NMS career or even someone who depends on outright gas. If we look back after 2028 and he's given us a couple of excellent years of service I would be very pleased for us and for him
